The Christopher, the Edgartown Collection

Just stayed two nights at the Christopher and had a great experience! The breakfast is continental with a mix of healthy and sweet treats. I had boiled eggs and chia seed pudding with coconut milk most mornings. They also had the option for hot and iced coffee which was an unexpected touch. I am also giving this 5 stars because of the friendly and helpful staff plus its convenient location to downtown. The room was well-appointed and a nice size for MV. We had a balcony facing the back which we enjoyed but the fan did not work so it did get hot sitting out there in the evening. While I'm giving this hotel 5 stars, there are a few things to mention. I was on the 2nd floor and the footsteps/noise above us were noticeable (which I was almost expecting since it's an older historical home) and our AC did not work well in our room. The other thing to mention is the common outdoor space is a little weathered. We thought we would hang outside but found it a bit tight and untidy. Overall, a 5-star experience but would try to get a room on the top floor for my next stay at the Christopher!

Staying at The Christopher was a wonderful experience! The location in Edgartown was perfect, the decor is tasteful with an island flair, the bed was comfy, morning breakfasts were yummy (especially the coconut chai pudding). Plus, warm chocolate chip cookies are served every day at 2 p.m.! All of the staff members that we encountered were welcoming and helpful. A special shoutout to Macayla who was particularly helpful and accommodating to us. She gave us great restaurant and places to see recommendations. Hope to visit The Christopher again soon!

Very beautiful hotel with friendly staff. The hotel was very clean and well maintained, there was a seamless service experience from the point we checked in, to the daily breakfast, and great recommendations about what to do in town. The rooms were impeccably clean, the breakfast was tasty, fresh cookies were provided in the afternoon and the property was beautiful. The location is also walking distance to the water and a lot of key attractions. Would highly recommend this hotel!

Well deserved of its traveller rating on TA. Excellent location in Edgertown, possibly the nicest town on MV, with off street parking and a stones throw from shops and restaurants. Lovely spacious rooms and very comfortable beds. Ours had a lovely balcony, great to chill out and relax upon. The host was super friendly and accommodating. A simple breakfast is included which is a nice touch. We really enjoyed our stay at the Christopher and would definitely stay again. Highly recommended.

Fantastic hotel, and the first place we will try to stay from here on in. Room was incredibly cozy and spacious, AMAZING bed, the hotel itself is on a beautiful, charming street, with Main St just a block away. Great area to walk around, restaurants, shops, etc. The hotel staff is wonderful, friendly and helpful. The breakfast was great.

A perfect stay from check in to check out! A peaceful retreat within Edgartown, walkable to everything! Clean, comfortable room with lovely staff. Loved the breakfast and water refilling station, so convenient. And you can’t beat a fresh baked cookie in the afternoon. There was a fire pit out back that we didn’t get an opportunity to enjoy but will have to next time!

Great location, rooms are extremely clean with a fresh scent, individual AC units in each room, friendly staff are available to assist and answer any questions, delicious light breakfast with organic products, free sun chairs and beach towels, convenient bike parking. Room 11 has a balcony where you can enjoy the hotel’s delicious fresh brewed coffee, see a bit of the harbor, and feel the lovely ocean breeze. It is on the top floor where there is no noise.

The Christopher was wonderful. Clean, quiet, beautifully decorated, and a superb location. I loved being so close to all the great shops and restaurants. Alison and staff were so helpful and accommodating and the check in/check out process was super simple. My only regret is that I wish I had stayed longer! I am so looking forward to my next visit

We loved our stay at the Christopher! The hotel was very clean, the assistant manager Helen was lovely and very knowledgeable of the area, and the location in the heart of Edgartown was perfect! Oh, and I can’t forget the delicious breakfast and home made cookies that were put out every afternoon! We will definitely be back!