Hotel Saint George

Overall: Not worth the money. I don't recommend. Fancy dressings (bath products, linens, etc), but poor fundamentals (room quality - bathroom fixture was held together with tape - and service) I was excited to stay here given the hotel's history, the minimalist aesthetic (in line with Marfa's art history), and the promise of a luxurious stay. I left feeling like I had paid much too much for the experience I received. The rooms look nice, and some of the touches (Aesop products, beautiful towels) are fantastic. But other parts of the rooms/hotel feel too cheap to command $400/night. The heavy room doors don't close softly, so you constantly hear doors slamming throughout the night as people come and go. The walls and ceilings are thin. And our toilet paper roll holder was held together with duct tape. The service was lacking, too. It felt very amateur for the price/luxury they are trying to project. People at the front desk didn't greet us. No one asked us how our stay was, even when we checked out. They seemed more interested in chatting to each other or eating at the desk than they did interacting with guests.

Meh. Poor service bordering on amateurish. Room cleaning was spotty. Arrived back from day out (after 4 pm) to unserviced room. Short on coffee cups and coffee in room most days . Front desk tried makes excuses that new arrivals get serviced first, but it was Sunday and there are not a lot of arrivals. No, not how this works. Restaurant and bar were frequently out of things (ribs, Bolognese, tomatoes, and various desserts). Gets tedious to have reselect and order a couple of times. And often slow; basic omelette took over an hour to arrive at table. Have had better service at half the price. Cannot recommend.

The Hotel St George is one of the best places to stay in the country. The staff are great, and the rooms, huge and luxurious. I always find that, when I stay here, it seems like home. I'm always remembered by the staff, who are quick to serve me and welcoming/friendly. The beds are amazing. Just the right firmness, and the suites are terrific. My wife and I come here often and this stay, almost two weeks, was truly the best vacation I can imagine. Heartily recommended.